Paper Clippings The Blog of The Crossroads Cultural Center
Paper Clippings, more than a classical blog, is a service providing valuable reading material in order to help readers reach a judgment about current affairs. Comments and discussion are more than welcome.
Michael Gerson (an evangelical Protestant) wades into Catholic social doctrine. At the end of the day, generating an original Catholic cultural judgment takes a lot of work and historically has not been one of the chief priorities of American Catholicism.
The decline of the humanities in US higher education after the 1980's is another example of the well-known "Del Noce's law": Marxist ideology leads by logical necessity to the triumph of bourgeois materialism.
Speaking of scientism, it has also the effect of hollowing out the educational system, by producing outstanding technicians who were never taught to ask questions about meaning and purpose.
There is a word for what David Brooks is trying to describe: common sense. The paradox is that he needs to invoke tons of "scientific studies" to legitimate a list of propositions that somebody like St. Augustine knew perfectly well, but that modern scientism has negated on purely ideological grounds. In fact, this very article shows that he still cannot break free from a scientistic mentality.
While Vladimir Bukovsky could use a less conspiratorial language, he makes two perceptive observations: a) that one of the big ideas of the European left in the 1980's was to achieve a "convergence" between Western Europe and the USSR, and b) that after the collapse of the Soviet Union, the same people adopted the EU as the vehicle of their revolutionary ideology.